Prev Next
Amalah
About the Author

Amy Corbett Storch

Amalah

Amalah is a pseudonym of Amy Corbett Storch. She is the author of the Advice Smackdown and Bounce Back. You can follow Amy’s daily mothering adventures at Ama...

Amalah is a pseudonym of Amy Corbett Storch. She is the author of the Advice Smackdown and Bounce Back. You can follow Amy’s daily mothering adventures at Amalah. Also, it’s pronounced AIM-ah-lah.

If there is a question you would like answered on the Advice Smackdown, please submit it to amyadvice@gmail.com.

Amy also documented her second pregnancy (with Ezra) in our wildly popular Weekly Pregnancy Calendar, Zero to Forty.

Amy is mother to rising first-grader Noah, preschooler Ezra, and toddler Ike.

icon icon
chat bubble icon

Comments

  • i love Amy’s advice for ignoring the behavior and not giving negative attention to the situation. she’s right my experience with “active ignoring” is that the negative behavior increases and then falls off a cliff. many parents give-in right before the cliff-fall.

    I would add, that if you’re going to practice “active ignoring” then you need to compensate it with praise of corresponding good behavior. In this case, I would seek out to praise the boys if they are following house/car rules and/or seated quietly together even if it’s in a car or at religious services or something, with “wow, you’re really following our house rules.” or, “i like the way you know when to sit together quietly when needed.” Then, of course, when they do go to sleep following your house rules, the next day, praise them with something like “wow, i really like how you were both quiet during bedtime or [fill in the blank].” I would recommend being specific.

    Good luck and tell us how it goes!

  • Jessica

    Amazing timing on this question. I was about to write an email with the same situation. My boys are 2 and 4 (no third baby in the way). When the two year old started climbing out of the crib we moved him to a toddler bed in his brother’s room so we can turn the nursery into a playroom/ guest room. The toddler goes to bed at 7 and plays for 45 minutes to an hour before going to sleep. The four year old gets extra parenting time before bed at 8. Putting them both to bed at the same time was a nightmare. A 2-3 hour long jumping, screaming, swinging from the curtains nightmare. My patience was not cut out for it. I’m hoping to try it again six months when the newness of freedom wears off for the younger one and the newness if room sharing wears off for both.

  • E’s Mommy

    Our boys were similar ages and had similar sleeping patterns when we moved them into the same room in bunk beds. Reading to them before bed it part of their bedtime routine. Our 2 year old would pick a picture book which we’d all read together, then they’d both get in bed and we’d read for 10-20 minutes from an easy chapter book (like Magic Treehouse) that the 4 year old picked. By that time the 2 year old would be asleep and the 4 year old would do whatever quietly in his bed until he fell asleep.

    That being said, I think Amy gave awesome advice that probably works better as a long term solution. My boys are 6 and 8 now and the youngest doesn’t fall asleep during reading anymore. There is a lot of talking and messing around before they fall asleep.

  • alexa

    I do pretty much the same thing. My 4 year old and 21 month old have shared a room for about a year now. They go to bed at the same time, and they both eventually go to sleep. They both tend to talk and sing to themselves and occasionally to each other.

    The little one is now in a toddler bed so she generally wanders out a few times before staying put and the oldest one will occasionally have a late night and sneak out of her room a few times. But we just put them back in bed, and eventually they stay put. Usually that only takes a few times occasionally it takes 5 times.

    You’re setting down a new routine, but everyone should get the hang of it soon. I’m with Amy though, once they are in bed, I don’t really care what they’re doing as long as they’re reasonably quiet and eventually go to sleep. It’s pretty dark in there, so they can’t get to crazy.

  • We’ll be going down this road sooner than later.  The oldest is 2.5 y/o, the youngest is 9 months.  Once the little one is reliably sleeping through the night (she still wakes up 2 or 3 times), then they will share a room.

    My guess is that it will be incredibly frustrating for a while, and then all of the sudden and for no apparent reason, everything will just sort of work out.  Parenting!

    • IrishCream

      Jimmy, that’s exactly how old my two girls are. We moved them in together…three months ago? Four? I have been amazed by how soundly my toddler sleeps through baby wake-ups. We’ve even done some CIO with the baby, and big sis was dead to the world. I don’t know if my daughter is an exceptionally sound sleeper, but hopefully it will be as easy for you when you’re ready as it was for us.

  • Ally

    We moved our boys in together when we moved houses and I think it made all the difference. It was a new environment with a lot of changes. They were 4 and 1 at the time. They do very well together, but we have also had the policy of not going into their rooms after we tuck them in. My daughter will sing for a long time, but I just let it go. 

    • Hillary

      Ha. I have a 3yo and an 8mo and if that baby wakes up and fusses for more than a minute, the 3yo SCREAMS at the top of her lungs that we need to get in there and take care of the baby. Like Amy suggests, we’re powering through. I feel like a winner because they both go to bed in the same room really well. Some nights they both sleep through the night! 2 steps forward, 1 step back.

  • KG

    Thanks for the advice. I realize now they are totally playing me. No interference will start tonight.

  • Thank you for sharing your story and for the advice. I agree with Amy on this. Back then, there was a lot of story telling and messing around with my kids before they sleep which really takes a lot from me. I can say that this is really an effective method because I used it before with my 2 little boys. 

  • MR

    Exactly what Amy said! My girls are about the same ages, and we have always done the same thing – ignore it. The only exception is if they are being really loud, I may tell them to quiet down, or if they are doing something where it seems like someone is going to get hurt, then I of course go in there. But, mostly I just listen because I think it is adorable the way they sing songs together or the way big sis reads to little sis, or rearranges the blankets so little sis can sleep on the floor (because that child hasn’t slept a night in a bed since we converted her to a toddler bed lol). I honestly don’t care if they are sleeping or not. They will go to sleep when they are ready, and in the meantime, I have the quiet time, which is what I need. And they WILL go to sleep when they are tired. Last night, my younger dd was out probably within two minutes of me leaving the room. Meanwhile, my older dd sang, read books out loud, and just generally played for an additional hour. And my youngest slept through it all. 🙂

  • Greta

    I have been having the same trouble as the original letter writer. It makes me both frantic and upset. By 8 p.m. I am so over anything and then I feel so guilty because I yell and bedtimes are such a nightmare.

    I googled this and came across your response. Amazing. It starts tonight. You are right. I need to recognize my duties and let them do their part. I can’t make them sleep but I can get them to bed at eight. Thanks!

  • Allison

    Okay… here’s my problem.  I have two boys (almost 6 and almost 7) who share a room.  My youngest rolls around, yells, and plays with his blankets and pillows.  My oldest lays there desperately trying to go to sleep while his brother thrashes around for 2 hours.  He will even (bless his little heart) sometimes get up and come out to the living room with a sweet little plea for me to get his brother to knock it off because he “can’t sleep.”  I feel for him because I can hear his brother on the other end of the house.  Ideas?

    • Michelle

      Did you ever figure out how to get the younger one to settle down?  I’m having the exact same issue with my 3 year old and 6 year old.  The poor 6 year old just wants to go to sleep.

  • Tiffini

    I must have epically challenging children, because I’ve already tried this. Our son sleeps in his room and our twins in the loft. If we ignore them, his door magically comes open, play time ensues, and they MIGHT be asleep by 10:30. Getting up by 7am for school is then a struggle and the twins will spend the morning being grouchy and my son has an issue at school with behavior because he’s tired. We’ve just accepted our lot in life – one of use sits on the couch in the loft and gives the twins nonstop shushing for an hour or so. Just sucks.

    • Christine

      Help! Me too! My 2 and 4-year-old boys started sharing a room 3 weeks ago, and we still are not settled. My 4-year-old is willing and ready to calm down and stay in bed and try to fall asleep.

      My 2-year-old is totally disruptive, won’t stay in bed, won’t stay in the room, and just says “Not tired. Not tired.” (At 8pm–He is ready for sleep!)

      I’m so tired of it. We put a pack-in-play in another room and he gets put in there if he can’s settle after 30 minutes. He actually prefers it and quiets down immediately when alone and contained. Makes me wonder if we should put them in separate rooms again? But that feels like moving backwards, and both boys seem like they would like it to work out in the long run.

  • erin

    Wow. I needed this tonight. Its 10:34 and my almost 3 year old and 20 month old are still up banging around in their room. My husband is out of town for 5 days and I have a 9 week old baby. I can’t spend an hour in their room getting them to fall asleep like we usually do when the hubs is home. So here I sit reading this realizing that if they dont fall asleep for another hour it will be ok. They will get tired eventually and they will (in a couple days ) start falling asleep when I put them down at 9 because theyre so stinking tired. So I will sit here and watch The Office while I wait for them to stop beating on the walls. Wherever they fall I will cover them up with a blanket and all is well. Theyre safe so whats the harm. Thank you. I needed this.

  • Staci

    Came across this last night as I was frantically googling “boys sharing room won’t sleep.”  We have 4 year old twin boys who share a room and, lately, the talking loudly, sitting on bed, playing with stuffed animals has gotten worse.  I confess to having a video monitor and trying to enforce a “you must stay on your bed and can only talk in quiet voices” rule.  This has resulted in myself and my husband going in there countless numbers of times to tell them to get back on their beds or quiet down, threatening them with taking away toys or privileges (and often doing it, to no avail) or putting one of them in a time-out.  Generally, it has made bedtimes very unpleasant for all of is  Last night, one of them was still awake at 10:30 and I finally surrendered.  I took this advice and told him he could look at a book or draw at his art desk….that he just needed to be quiet so the rest of us could sleep (his brother had finally fallen asleep).  I turned off the baby monitor.  And, eventually, he did fall asleep.  Tonight, I’m just going to put them to bed a bit earlier and see if they tire themselves out.  I think I have been trying to control something that is not really within my control.   Thanks for the well written advice!  

  • June

    So to echo someone else, what do you do when one wants to sleep and the other doesn’t?  Do you enforce ground rules of switching to a quiet activity when the other one wants to sleep?

  • Melinda

    I have a 3.5 year old and a 2.5 year old both boys, and a gorgeous 12 year Old daughter she was a great baby no trouble at all particularly at bedtime went to bed no problems, my 3.5 year old has been sleeping next to me for about 5 months I did this bcos I loved it for one and bcos they were sharing it was just easier getting them to bed, and if sick they would both sleep better apart, it was the worst mistake ever! Bcos now he has separation anxiety without me sleeping next to him, night two tonight of him being in his car bed next to his brother in his cot, everytime I leave he screams, he gets out I put him back this happened like ten times a smack on the bum didn’t work either so I tried the corner for 4 mins, put him back to bed a firm cuddle stayed with him for around 3 mins, and said if u get out of bed again you go in the naughty corner, finally he’s asleep the naughty corner worked, my heart is now breaking as he’s not in with mummy tonight 🙁 I’ll miss him, as I’m separated from my husband ATM, I know he’s going to wake later and I’m dreading it 🙁 any suggestions, i can’t put him in the naughty corner early hours of the morning, ohhh it’s going to be a long night I think, I know eventually the anxiety of him being without mummy will ease, and him and his brother will go back to giggles again and eventually crash, fingers crossed!! Any suggestions guys? Would be appreciated, or has anyone gone through something similar? Cheers

    • Melissa

      Hi Melinda,
      One thing i have found works with separation anxiety is the Ferber method. Before you leave the room, tell him you will check on him in five minutes. And then be sure to come back in five minutes and repeat again until he falls asleep. The next night, do 10 minute increments. And so on. Eventually, the separation gets easier because he understands you are still near.

  • Anna

    I have a similar problem. I have a 3yr son and 1yr daughter. My daughter is still in a crib and my son has this…. obsession with piling his toys… well….. everywhere. It gets worse at bedtime/naptime because he enjoys piling his toys in his sister’s crib. With his sister. He then finds it necessary to climb into the crib with her, usually hurting her in the process. He also puts her bottle down her foot-y pjs so she cannot get it out. We live in a two bedroom house so separate rooms is not an option. My husband is at his wits ends! If they were just talking back and forth it wouldn’t be an issue but I cannot ignore my daughter getting hurt. This can go on for up to 5 hours. It doesn’t even work to put my daughter down first and then put him to bed when she is asleep. He just wakes her up. PLEASE HELP!!!!!!!

  • Emma

    Anna, I think you might want to consider moving the bubba into your room until the little guy can resist the temptation of using her bed as a playground. My older boys were only 3yrs and 15 months when the baby was born, and their favourite place to sit was his little crib. Usually with him in it. 

    My gang are also driving me nuts. If there was only one of them, they didn’t disturb each other, or didn’t have school the next day I really wouldn’t give two hoots. However, the 9 year old son already suffers from insomnia and has been falling asleep at school. His schoolwork is definitely affected, and his mood is awful. He has hysterical tantrums when he’s been up till 11. The 7 year old takes a long time to wind down and is a bit of a singer, and the 6 year old is just a party animal. Those two go to bed at the same time (about 7:30) usually with a story and then maybe a story/music cd on quietly. Pretty much every night they’re up jumping on beds, playing with torches, toys, trashing the place. The 9 year old sneaks chocolate to bed then complains that he can’t sleep. I go in repeatedly and threaten with xbox bans and cancelled playdates (and stick to my guns) but still they’re up goofing around until 10 if I let them. And they’re monsters the next day. It’s only when I properly lose the plot (usually after about two hours) that they will SOMETIMES stop. 

  • Joanna

    To revisit the above two comments/questions above that weren’t answered, what if one desperately wants to sleep and the other desperately wants to jump on top of the sleepers face repeatedly? I would buy that the jumper just wants my attention but the one trying to sleep just wants to sleep… Or throttle the jumper

    • Michelle

      Ever figure it out?  I’m having this issue at the moment and I’m at my wit’s end.

  • Joelle

    Hello. Thank you for your down to earth article which inspired the following solution for my kids. After they are ready for bed I read a story to them in the playroom. After the story they have the choice of talking quietly or reading. When they feel tired they go into the bedroom where there is strictly no talking and bugging the child who wants to sleep. It works really well and I am out of the picture and can have some me time and they feel impowered. Hope this can help someone.

  • Jess

    Bedtime is my worst nightmare at the moment. My 4 year old and six year old daughters have shared a room for years perfectly but recently my six year old has really started playing up at bed time. It starts with one more glass of water, one more kiss, one more cuddle, tuck me in, tuck me in again and again and another kiss etc then escalates. I’m on my own so although I try my hardest I do end up loosing my temper. If I try to leave the room she will start screaming then come out and demand cuddles. I can’t just leave her as she will later demand to be tucked in. Now my easy going 4 year old has started copying and my whole bedtime routine that kept us all sane is falling apart. I figured with all the mummy mummy mummy she was feeling insecure so I (stupidly) started to sit in the room with her whilst she fell asleep, she still tries it on but does eventually go off to sleep now but where do I draw the line….. Any suggestions to my nightmare???!,

  • Aimee

    Great advice, but what if they are keeping the school age children up because they are so loud?? As I write this my 2 little guys (4 and 3) have been up for 2 hours-playing, wrestling, screaming, banging into the walls, occasionally sneaking down stairs…you get the picture. My 11 year old has a test in the am and needs to sleep. We put the little guys to bed an hour before the big guys in hopes they’ll crash before the big kids go to bed.
    Thanks!!

  • Lols

    Same exact issue w 3 and 5 yo. I have to cosleep with younger one and tell the 5yo to go to my room and sleep. Expecting #3 and don’t have the patience!!

  • Pingback: How to Make Sharing a Bedroom More Manageable for Your Kids()

  • Grave

    Wow, this was such a helpful post for me. It also brought back memories of when I was younger and shared a room with my brothers. We would stay up for so long talking about our day and things that we thought were important. I’ve been doing exactly what the momma with the question was doing (bribery). And it doesn’t work and as you ever so bluntly pointed out, they always get their treat the next day because I feel bad… I am currently laying in bed while I listen to my girls talk (mostly scream) wanting to go in their room but knowing that it will just drag things out. Well anyways, Thanks! I’m gonna try this and hopefully gain my sanity!